The Psychology of Edward Scissorhands: Difference, Othering, and the Longing to Belong

The Psychology of Othering

The community's treatment of Edward illustrates the psychology of othering, the process by which those who are different are perceived as fundamentally other, as not fully belonging to the community of ordinary people, and are thereby made subject to fear, exclusion, and mistreatment. Othering is a substantive psychological and social process, the perception of those who are different as belonging to a category apart from and often beneath the perceiver's own group. Through othering, the different person is perceived not as a fellow member of a shared human community but as fundamentally other, their difference marking them as not one of us. This removes them from the community of concern and makes them subject to the treatment that the other, unlike one of us, can receive. The film is particularly astute in depicting the community's initial embrace of Edward as a novelty, which precedes its later rejection. This progression, from fascination to rejection, captures a substantive truth about the reception of difference: that the different can be objects of fascination as well as fear, and that the fascination can give way to rejection when the difference comes to seem threatening rather than merely interesting.

Difference as a Screen for Projection

The film illustrates the way that the different person can become a screen for the community's projections, blamed for problems and perceived as threatening in ways that reflect the community's fears rather than the reality of the different person. The outsider, already othered, is a convenient screen for these projections. Projection, the psychological process by which one's own feelings, fears, or qualities are attributed to another, can operate at the level of communities as well as individuals, the community projecting its collective fears and suspicions onto the outsider, who becomes a screen for what it fears or disowns. Edward becomes such a screen, the community projecting onto him fears and suspicions that his actual gentleness does not warrant, perceiving him as threatening in ways that reflect their projections rather than his reality. The film heightens the poignancy of this by making Edward not merely harmless but genuinely gentle, genuinely good, so that the community's perception of him as threatening is not merely mistaken but a profound injustice, a rejection of goodness itself, the community's fear and projection blinding it to the actual worth of the one it drives out.

The Loneliness of the Outsider

At the film's heart is the loneliness of Edward's position as an outsider, the profound isolation of one who does not belong, who is set apart by a difference he cannot help and cannot overcome. To be different in a way that sets one apart from the community, that prevents full belonging, is to experience a profound loneliness, the isolation of one who does not fit, who cannot fully connect. This loneliness is intensified when the difference is visible and cannot be hidden, when it marks the person as other in a way that cannot be concealed, foreclosing even the partial belonging that a hidden difference might allow. The film deepens this loneliness through Edward's capacity for love and connection, his longing to belong and to be close to others, which makes his isolation the more painful. Edward is not indifferent to connection; he longs for it, is capable of love, desires to belong, and this longing makes his isolation the more painful, the belonging he desires foreclosed by the difference he cannot overcome. For children who feel set apart, this loneliness is real, and learning how to help a child make and keep friends can be a lifeline against it.

The Gifts of Difference

The film suggests, poignantly, that Edward's difference is not only a source of his rejection but also of his gifts, that the very difference that sets him apart is also the source of the extraordinary beauty he creates. His scissor hands, the mark of his difference and the source of his rejection, are also the instruments of his art, the means by which he creates the extraordinary topiary and ice sculptures that express his gentle soul. This captures a substantive truth: the very qualities that mark a person as different, that expose them to othering and rejection, can also be the source of distinctive gifts, of capacities and perspectives and creations that sameness would not produce. Difference is not only a liability but can be a source of distinctive contribution. Yet the film is honest that Edward's gifts do not save him from rejection. A community can benefit from and admire the gifts of the different while still othering and rejecting them, the appreciation of the gift coexisting with the rejection of the person. This honesty tempers the hopeful note with the painful recognition that gifts do not always protect against rejection.

Reflections for the Viewer

Edward Scissorhands became a beloved modern fairy tale, its visual beauty and emotional depth winning it an enduring place in audiences' affections. For viewers responding to its beauty, it offers a work of great visual and emotional richness. For viewers responding to its substance, it offers a poignant engagement with difference, othering, and the experience of the outsider. For viewers who have themselves experienced othering, who have been set apart and rejected for a difference they could not help, the film offers a profound recognition. Its depiction of Edward, gentle and good yet rejected for a difference he could not help, may offer recognition of your experience and a validation of its injustice, the rejection reflecting the failure of those who reject rather than any fault in the one rejected. This is a kinship the film shares with a story like Zootopia, which also asks who gets treated as a them and what belonging really costs. And for viewers reflecting on their own participation in othering, the film offers a substantive invitation. Othering is a common process, and most people participate in it in some measure, perceiving and treating the different as other in ways they may not fully recognize. The film's depiction of the community's rejection of the gentle Edward invites reflection on one's own othering, on the fears and projections that may distort one's perception of those who are different, and on the shared humanity that othering obscures. For a child, the ache of being left out can also show up as worry or withdrawal, and it helps to know the signs of anxiety in children. A few questions are worth sitting with: Where have I felt set apart by a difference I could not help? Who around me might feel like an outsider right now? Where might my own fear or discomfort be turning someone into a "them"?

Frequently asked questions