The Psychology of Rudy: Grit, Self-Determination, and the Refusal to Quit

The Psychology of Grit

Rudy's defining quality is what the psychologist Angela Duckworth has called grit, the combination of passion and perseverance toward long-term goals. Grit, in Duckworth's account, is the disposition to pursue a goal with sustained passion and sustained effort over long periods, through setbacks and plateaus and discouragement, maintaining commitment to the goal across the years that its achievement requires. It is distinct from talent; a person can have great talent and little grit, pursuing goals fitfully and abandoning them at the first obstacle, or modest talent and great grit, pursuing goals relentlessly across years of effort. Duckworth's research suggests that grit, this sustained passion and perseverance, is a significant predictor of achievement, often more significant than talent alone. Rudy exemplifies grit in nearly pure form. He lacks talent, the athletic gifts that would make his goal easy, but he possesses extraordinary grit, sustained passion for his goal and sustained perseverance toward it across years of effort and setback. Where a person of greater talent but lesser grit might have achieved the goal easily or abandoned it at the first obstacle, Rudy, lacking the talent, achieves through grit what his limited gifts would never have achieved alone.

The Cost of Grit

What the film also illustrates is the cost of grit, the sacrifices and the sustained effort that the pursuit of a difficult goal through grit requires. Rudy's grit is not effortless; it demands years of grueling work, sacrifice, and the endurance of repeated discouragement. Grit is not a comfortable quality but a demanding one, requiring the sustained effort and the endurance of setbacks that the pursuit of a difficult goal across years involves. The film does not romanticize Rudy's grit as easy but depicts its cost, the years of effort, the sacrifices, the endurance of discouragement, that his pursuit of his goal requires. This honest depiction of the cost of grit captures a substantive truth, that grit, valuable as it is, is demanding, that the sustained passion and perseverance it involves require real and sustained effort and the endurance of real setbacks and discouragement. Learning to sit with that discouragement without being ruled by it is closely related to what we discuss in recognizing signs of anxiety in teenagers, where the pressure of difficult goals can weigh heavily on a young person.

The Sources of Motivation

The film invites reflection on the sources of Rudy's extraordinary motivation, on what drives his relentless pursuit of a goal that everyone tells him is impossible. Part of Rudy's motivation appears to come from a desire to prove himself, to demonstrate his worth against a world and a family that have doubted him. But the film suggests that his deeper motivation is a genuine passion for the goal itself, a love of Notre Dame football and a desire to be part of it that is intrinsic to the goal rather than merely instrumental. Rudy wants to play for Notre Dame not primarily for what it will get him but for the sake of the thing itself, for the intrinsic meaning the goal holds for him. The distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation is substantively important to understanding perseverance. Extrinsic motivation, the pursuit of a goal for external rewards or to prove oneself to others, can drive effort, but it is often less sustaining than intrinsic motivation, the pursuit of a goal for its own sake, for the inherent meaning or satisfaction it holds. Research on motivation, including the self-determination theory developed by Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, suggests that intrinsic motivation tends to be more sustaining and more conducive to persistence and wellbeing than extrinsic motivation. Rudy's motivation, while it includes an extrinsic element of proving himself, appears to be grounded substantially in intrinsic passion, and this intrinsic passion may be part of what sustains his extraordinary perseverance.

A Dream That Is Genuinely His Own

The film's engagement with self-determination theory extends to its treatment of Rudy's autonomy, his pursuit of a goal that is genuinely his own rather than one imposed by others. Rudy's dream is authentically his, chosen by him against the expectations of his family and the pressures of his environment, an expression of his own genuine passion rather than a goal imposed from outside. Self-determination theory emphasizes the importance of autonomy, of pursuing goals that are genuinely one's own, to motivation and wellbeing; goals that are authentically chosen tend to be pursued with greater commitment and to contribute more to wellbeing than goals imposed by others. Rudy's autonomous pursuit of his own genuine dream, against the expectations of others, reflects this principle, the authenticity of the goal as his own contributing to the commitment with which he pursues it. His dream is his, and this ownership is part of what sustains his relentless pursuit of it.

The Meaning of the Goal Itself

One of the film's most substantive features is its suggestion that the value of Rudy's pursuit lies substantially in the pursuit itself, in the meaning the goal holds for him and the growth the pursuit produces, rather than solely in the final achievement. Rudy's years of effort, his growth through the pursuit, his sustained commitment to a meaningful goal, have value in themselves, apart from whether he ultimately achieves the goal. While the achievement of a goal can be satisfying, much of the meaning and growth associated with goals comes from the pursuit itself, from the disciplined commitment, the effort, the growth that the pursuit produces, rather than solely from the final achievement. A meaningful goal pursued with sustained commitment provides purpose, structure, and growth throughout the pursuit, independent of whether the goal is ultimately achieved. When Rudy does, at last, achieve a version of his goal, playing in a game for Notre Dame in the film's climax, the achievement is moving precisely because of the pursuit that preceded it, the years of effort and sacrifice and perseverance that give the achievement its meaning. A person of greater talent achieving the same thing easily would not move us. It is moving because of the grit and the perseverance and the sustained commitment that Rudy brought to it.

The Role of Believing Others

Though Rudy's grit is his own, the film is attentive to the role of the few who believe in him, who support his improbable dream against the discouragement of the many. A groundskeeper who befriends him, a priest who counsels him, a tutor who helps him, and eventually teammates who come to respect him, provide Rudy with the support and belief that sustain his pursuit. These believing others, few against the many who doubt him, provide a support that helps Rudy to persist, their belief in him bolstering his own belief in his goal. The role of supportive others in sustaining perseverance toward a difficult goal is substantive. Even the grittiest individual benefits from the support and belief of others, from figures who encourage the pursuit, who believe in the goal, who provide the support that the long pursuit requires. The belief of others can bolster one's own belief, can provide encouragement in moments of discouragement, can offer the practical and emotional support that a difficult pursuit requires. The same current of belief and team-forged perseverance runs through the psychology of Cool Runnings. The film's climax, in which Rudy's teammates rally to support him, advocating for his chance to play, captures the culmination of this support, the community that comes, at last, to believe in and honor Rudy's grit. Sustained grit can eventually win the belief and support of others, the perseverance which the many doubt earning, at last, their respect.

Reflections for the Viewer

Rudy became a beloved inspirational film, its story of improbable perseverance resonating with audiences. For viewers responding to its inspiration, the film offers a stirring underdog story. For viewers responding to its substance, the film offers a thoughtful study of grit, motivation, and the meaning of a goal pursued for its own sake. For viewers pursuing their own difficult goals, the film offers both encouragement and a realistic understanding of what perseverance requires. The encouragement is that grit, sustained passion and perseverance, can achieve what talent alone would not, that a person of limited gifts but extraordinary determination can accomplish remarkable things through sustained effort. The realistic understanding is that grit is demanding, that the pursuit of a difficult goal requires years of effort, sacrifice, and the endurance of setbacks and discouragement. At the same time, a thoughtful engagement with the film can hold its inspirational message alongside a realistic recognition that grit does not guarantee success, that perseverance, however admirable, does not always achieve its goal. Rudy achieves his goal, but many who pursue difficult goals with equal grit do not, their perseverance meeting obstacles that determination cannot overcome. The more nuanced lesson is that grit makes achievement more likely and that the pursuit itself has value, not that grit guarantees success. Helping a child build a sense of worth that can hold steady whether or not a goal is reached is the subject of our guide on how to build confidence in children. A few questions are worth sitting with: What goals am I pursuing for their own sake, and which am I pursuing only to prove something to others? Where in my life has the pursuit itself, and not only the outcome, given me meaning? Who has believed in me when others doubted, and whom do I believe in now?

Frequently asked questions